Oblomovka

2002-12-05»

David Docherty, a man who, when he wasn't bemoaning the immoral anarchy of the Net , was hiring "viral marketeers" to spam newsgroups with fake environmental groups to plug his new novel, finally departed his job at Telewest. His title was "Head of Broadband Content", which is like being "Man In Charge Of What People Should Say On The Telephone".

In his parting shot in the Guardian, he says that we're a "cookie monster" generation, who want everything to be free. He says that the programmers behind P2P are "like Fagin in Oliver Twist - they just want to pick a pocket or two". And that's why broadband has failed, apparently.

I can't think of a single word to say, except: how did he last so long? See ya, Chicken Dance Elmo. Hope you do better in a market intended to promote fictions.

Summary: we don't know, even if some people claim to. Energy-industry sponsored researcher Mark Mills told everyone it was around 13% of the total U.S. electricity output, in stories like the famous Forbes cry "Dig more coal -- the PCs are coming". The figure was bandied around as a reason for the California blackouts - even as it become obvious that the crazy power prices were down to a faulty deregulatory market and outright manipulation by Enron. Now WSJ columnist David Wessel points to a competing Berkeley report that says its closer to 3%. And admits that the chances are we don't know. But what's important is to admit we don't know.

"When people hear a statistic that matches their assumptions about how the world is going, they tend not to question it," Mr. Koomey says. That was especially so during the euphoria-induced gullibility of the late 1990s, when WorldCom Inc.'s UUNet subsidiary started an avalanche with the catchy, but false, claim that Internet traffic was doubling every 100 days.

Old assumptions demand re-examination. Are forecasts for electricity demand proving wrong? Some issues demand debate. How much potential does conservation really have? What's the wisest way to be sure we have enough energy for the future? What should government do or not do to ensure that our children and grandchildren live better? What is best left to the market?

But no good comes from pretending we know more than we do or from treating suppositions as truths.

So Quinn and I went over to the Internet Archive and interviewed Brewster Kahle about - well, whatever he wanted to talk about. I started with a list of the current Brewster projects I knew about - the Internet Archive, his donation of a copy of the Internet Archive to the Library of Alexandria, the Internet Bookmobile, his plan to light up most of San Francisco with free WiFi, his amicus curiae in the Eldred case, the September 11th archive, the Wayback Machine... he picked the bookmobile, and we talked binding technology, how books on demand now means its a buck-a-book at quantities of one or more, the future role of librarians, the collateral damage of the 1976 copyright law, how to get kids printing Dickens instead of selling drugs, and what happens if he got run over by a bus.

I'll try and put up my notes after the Irish Times piece is finished, but if I don't, here are the key blogworthy bits:

Firstly, the Internet Archive is in San Francisco's Presidio which is a historic ex-military post that magically turned into a park in 1994. I don't yet have an easy way of describing the feel of the place, but my notes say "Like a colonial version of 'The Prisoner'" and "Americana-ville, Federalsburg". It has its own law enforcement, fire and medical services. It's very hard to estimate who lives there: my guess was all the ex-presidents, from Washington onwards. I expected to see Thomas Jefferson pass me on a golf cart.

The Internet Archive office looks like the village schoolhouse. I meant to ask Kahle how they snagged an office there, but we forgot. I forgot a lot of things; he's somewhat of a firehose. Usually it's pretty hard for an interviewee get a word in edgeways with me, but Brewster managed it.

Remember Rafe's blog entry about how 93% of pre-1946 copyrighted films are unavailable? I told Brewster and he said, well, they're doing better than the world of books. 98% of currently copyrighted books are out of print and effectively unobtainable.

Of course, there's not much he can do about the stuff imprisoned in copyright. But there's still the public domain. The Archive has plans to scan 1,000,000 public domain books by 2005. If you'd like to contribute your own, pre-Disney works, just scan 'em in page by page as TIFFs and send them to the Archive. They'll keep them for you, and for the whole of posterity.

He also wants to help libraries to start scanning in their PD collections too; make librarys' access to their works a two-way street. He quotes Michael "Project Gutenberg" Hart:

We have the technology to take the history of the world to your town, and the history of your town to the world.

It's a tragedy that children don't have access to the whole of the public domain. This is what the Bookmobile jaunt was for - to show people the value of the public domain. (The Bookmobile would drive up to schools, set up their satellite dish, let a kid pick a book, and print and bind it for them, then and there. Cost a buck a book. They paid a dollar, and got to keep a book for the rest of their life.)

He talked about his grandfather's book collection, how so many of those books are unavailable now. He wants to give the collection to his children. But he has two children. Where is he going to get another copy of these out-of-print books? His grandfathers been dead forty years: his library should have passed onto everyone.

"The history of libraries is this: they get burnt down. By governments. I'm not anti-government: I'm a librarian, not a libertarian. But that's the truth."

And lots, lots more. I keep hearing him say "we can make a different world, by building it", which sounds clumsy copied from my notes, but in context, spoken by Brewster Kahle in an old wooden house with a bunch of commodity web servers in one corner, a whiteboard with plans to scan a million books on the wall to the left, and shelf with a freshly minted Alice in Wonderland and his federally-printed submission to the Supreme Court behind me, it made me think of Patrick and Theresa Nielsen Hayden's motto:

Work like you were living in the early days of a better nation

I need to record these things on tape and upload them, don't I?

2002-12-04»

Much more detailed info than the keynote is Trevor Marshall's talk on security and antenna design and how not to leak signals in directions you don't want. Or, alternately, given that Marshall designed a parabolic feed that secured a 125Km WiFi link using standard Cisco cards, how to leak in exactly the directions you do want.) I suspect the talk is similiar to the one he gave to the SoCal Wireless Users group, which is streamed on the Linux Public Broadcasting Network if you want to learn more.

He also has some ugly-ass plots of PCMCIA antenna signal strengths (below - the two colours are different polarisations). WiFi card signals are all over the place, which I found out to my cost when I was trying to write a triangulating utility a while back.

I'm blogging Sky Dayton's keynote at 802.11 planet. There's not been much that's new, but it's a nice overview of Sky's take on the market.

Sky's "ah-ha" moment was when he was in Aspen, and he saw three APs in his hotel room. Two turned out to be wireless ISPs - both of whom starting scrapping between each other to talk to him. Reminded him of early days of Earthlink.

Survey says: 97% of travelling businessmen would alter their plans to gravitate to high-speed access (high-speed access is more important to them than wireless access)

Ubiquity in laptops - Dell will be putting WiFi in their laptops by default, new iPaq will have WiFi built in.

He sees WiFi in cellphones, cars, gameboys. How low can the power go on these things, I wonder? There must be some physical limit. Maybe we just need more sensitive APs? Sorry, mind wandering - back to Sky.

Only 3,000 commercial hotspots in the US - about a million potential locations (212 conference centers, 3032 train stations, 5352 airports, 72,720 business centers, 202,600 gas stations, 480,298 restaurants and cafes, 1,111,300 retail stores. Wow. There are more airports than train stations in the US.)

But how do you get to ubiquity?

Dayton compares it to early days of ISPs ("Nobody knew who was their customer and who was their competition"). Back then, everybody tried to do everything - owning the wires, the network, and the brands. Eventually each company concentrated in one area - end users are AOL, MSN, networks are UUNET etc, wires are the telcos. (Hmmm. Has this happened in broadband yet?)

Dayton's division in the WiFi market is: Venues (Mariot, Hilton, Borders, etc). Hot Spot Operators: "(Wayport, T-Mobile, Surf and Sip, etc). Aggregators, who take the fragmented networks and provide cohesion: Boingo, GRIC, iPass. And brands: Boingo, T-Mobile, Earthlink, Sprint, Cingular, AT&T.

Big potential, says Sky, is in Hot Spot Operators. Two aggregators max. But he would say that...

He believes that no one HSO (Hot Spot Operator) will be able to deploy more than 10% of the total footprint - because WiFi's short range, low barrier to entry, and venue fragmentation. If your brother runs a chain of coffee shops, you could set up a HSO and roll it out, and steal past any bigger HSO. That's why aggregators are necessary.

Mac version of Boingo sniffer in Q1 2003. Not much talk about *how* it aggregates with HSO.

Some nattering about Hot Spot in a Box - allows any access point becomes a commercial hot spot. Costs $500 includes hardware, will drop to $300 as they talk to major manufacturers -- any broadband end point could become a hotspot. There must be a way of turning that into a software app. What kind of cut do these Boingo resellers get?

Hardware with Boingo built-in: Nomadix, Colubris, and Vernier. Fairly minor players. Client software carried with Orinoco, D-Link, SMC, Netgear, HP laptops, Earthlink (doh), Fiberlink. Yeah, but who pays attention to the CDs in the box?

Audience seem a bit underwhelmed. You can see that WiFi is taking off: lots of low-attention-span wide-eyed MBA wolverines sniffing and snarling their business plans on the floor. They already know Sky's overview - they want to know what everyone is going to do for them, or what they can do to everyone else.

The conference is much much bigger than last year, but I think the smarts has got a bit more dilute. Ah, well - once more into the J-curve...

Now, should find Glen and feed him some Theraflu?

A friend wrote asking me if a petabyte would be an affordable amount of disk storage in five years time. Blowed if I know, but in scrabbling to answer, I did find this great projection of the next twenty years of magnetic storage. It contains this graph which is based on IBM estimates of future storage capacity and price. (which I couldn't be bothered to convert into HTML - hey, but maybe you will and sent the text to me. Updated 2004-07-11: For my birthday, Adrian Furby sent me this HTMLised. Thanks, Adrian!)

As you can see, a petabyte will still cost about $70,000 in 2008. Consolation prize: a terabyte will sell for $70. Better start saving those files now!

According to a cursory IMDB search, Jason Schultz has discovered that 93% of the movies released from 1927-1946 are unavailable (it'd be interesting to include current TV showings in this - what was that site that let you grep through US TV listings for keywords?). As an interesting aside, the IMDB has 36,386 titles for that period. The copyright office says there are 37,144 - which means that the IMDB, a largely amateur effort, has snagged 98% of the titles. All goes to show that Kevin Kelly's assertion that enthusiasts might be better at preserving film history than paid copyright holders might turn out to be true. (Off of the rc3.org)

2002-12-03»

A new and better patch for the old linux-wlan on the 2.4 kernel; an addition to How To Wash Dishes that was meant to be added in March (sorry Dave.)

A lesson in game design, hosted on IRC.

How many inhabitants does Sunnydale need to support its apparently limitless supply of vampires? Brian Thomas, PhD candidate in ecology at Stanford, investigates. (From More Like This)

It's December, so it must be time for the Perl Advent Calendar: one CPAN module explained (with brief tutorial) every day. Day one taught me about finding URLs in text, day two explained how to write to files in place with automatic data recovery if it all goes wrong, and day three showed me a all-Perl Perl-and-C mini-SQL database in less than 300KB.

2002-12-02»

I use public transport a lot - even in Silicon Valley, where it sucketh like the Black Hole of Calcutta. To do so in such bus and train deadzone requires exactly the kind of juggling of schedules and careful dead-reckoning navigation that I am utterly lame at.

This is why I depend on online journey planners (like these versions for San Francisco and London). I also walk around quite a bit, trying hard not to get lost. A little pocket GPS and an online street address to latitude/longitude converter have revolutionised my wanderings, around and apart from public transport trips. I hardly ever get lost anymore, and I rarely underestimate how long it will take to get somewhere.

There's just a whole stack of destinations that this tech has let me see are perfectly reachable without a car, even in California.

Now add into the mix services like NextBus, which monitors and shares info on the realtime position of all the buses in San Francisco. Wrap it all into some portable device (or wireless service), that lets me provide an street address, and plots a route and ETA on the fly.

I feel confident with more realtime info, and realtime positioning, a lot more folk would be tempted by public transport, or indeed walking, than now.

That it takes slightly longer to get places doesn't bother me - I get a lot more done on a bus or train than I do even as a passenger in a car. The cost is a pain in the Valley ($4.00 for a day pass), but in most decently-run trans areas that burden is less acute.

No, the largest hurdle public transport has to overcome, I think, is the feeling of powerlessness and unpredictability it induces in most people. I think you can go a long way to reducing that - without requiring any heavy initial investments in public transport itself, by harnassing this new tech. It'll never be for anyone - but it's certainly increased my usage, and appreciation of, even one of the flimsiest public trans system in the world.

2002-12-01»

So I googled for a biography of Winston Churchill, and this was the second hit. It's a fine potted history, but ends on an odd note:

...During all of his life he had served no less than six British monarchs: Queen Victoria, Edward VII, George IV, Edward VIII, George VI and Elisabeth II.

He also possessed a large collection of toy soldiers. However in his book 'My Early Life' he does not mention which make of soldiers he collected. They were probably all made between 1880 and 1900 and therefore some time before Lineol and Hausser figures became available. As a collector he might be the only one of whom also a personality figure was produced.

... and then I realise. This is the biography of Winston Churchill, as it affects the world of toy soldiers. Did that make it any less useful, though?

2002-11-30»

SpinSanity is exactly the sort of site that I don't visit as much as I'd like, but would read every day in a RSS reader like NetNewsWire. And now they've added a RSS feed, I can. Hooray!

Except I'm not using OS X much these days, so I don't have an RSS reader. Time to play around with Straw.

Over seven hundred slides from Peter Gutman's Godzilla Crypto Tutorial. I imagine aliens flipping through this in about thirty seconds to absorb all current knowledge regarding the uses and abuses of crypto. Not particularly mathematically heavy-weight, but pretty techie in parts. The seventy-one slide guide to crypto politics is pretty comprehensive (not entirely up to date though). I got this from the enhyper financial crypto digital library mailing list, which occasionally turns up some great resources.

And I thought burning a video of the ultrasound onto CD-ROM was high-tech. This New Mexico firm is doing 3D ultrasound images, with a haptic interface so you can reach out (in?) and touch your unborn child. I admit to being mildly freaked.

2002-11-28»

One of the first cross-cultural fidgets I learnt in America: the English use "please" on more occasions than Americans do; OTOH Americans expect "thank-you" when English people wouldn't miss it at all (or would be deploying it sarcastically). So this is one way we manage to sound rude and overpolite to each other at the same time. So, thanks. Thanks!

Anyway: New get your war on. New reverse-link engine to see who is linking to your blog.

Rupert Goodwins did the BBC interview on Palladium I mentioned. He says that the Microsoft rep, Stuart Okin said that Pd was being pushed by Microsoft to become TCPA 1.2. That's to say, not complement or extend, but actively replace the old standard. Anyone heard this said in public before?